We use cookies. These cookies enhance your experience and improve our website. Certain cookies are necessary and can't be turned off, but we also allow others to place cookies to track the performance of our website and deliver personalized content and ads. You can select your preference using the buttons.


Hosting? We'll help you bring something special to the table.


MEET OUR THANKSGIVING MENU
The holidays are our favorite time of year. Gathering with loved ones. Making new memories.
And sharing an unforgettable meal—the kind where you can taste love and care in every bite.
For years, we’ve been honored to cater celebrations for so many of our neighbors. And this Thanksgiving,
our chefs have pulled out all the stops with a menu that’s ready to impress. Here’s what you can expect:
From tender, juicy turkey to warmly spiced pumpkin pie.
SPECIALTY DISHES
Like our signature stuffings and cranberry conserve.
CATERING PLATTERS & TRAYS
Covering brunch to dessert—and everything in between.
EASY ORDERING
Whether you’d prefer online, calling or emailing,
or stopping by in person.
OUR SIGNATURE SEAFOOD
Available for nationwide, overnight shipping, as well as
local pickup and delivery.
EXPERT RESOURCES
Tips for carving turkey, arranging cheese boards,
and warming our chef-prepared specialties.
FEATURED RECIPES
In the mood to cook? Add these to your menu.
GIFT INSPIRATION
We have something delicious for every occasion.
(And flowers, too.)
WHERE IS HOLIDAY CATERING AVAILABLE?
See if you’re near a Citarella location.
WHAT IF I MISS THE ORDERING CUT-OFF DATES?
Don’t worry—you still have plenty of delicious options.
THANKSGIVING MENU HIGHLIGHTS
We’ve curated our menu with options for every kind of celebration—whether you’re looking for a multi-course,
fully prepared feast, or want to order a few dishes individually to complement your homemade dinner.
CHEF-PREPARED FEASTS


TURKEY
FEAST FOR EIGHT | Whole Turkey $499 ($63 per person)
EVERYTHING BUT THE TURKEY FEASTS
Roasting your own turkey? Let us take care of everything
else, from side dishes to the perfect pumpkin pie.
FEAST FOR EIGHT | $375 ($47 per person)


EACH TURKEY FEAST INCLUDES:
Pumpkin Bisque • Autumn Lasagna • Sautéed Brussels Sprouts
Sautéed String Beans • Cranberry Conserve • Chicken Bone Broth
Turkey Gravy • Sweet Potato Purée • Chunky Mashed Potatoes
Wild Rice Stuffing • Cornbread • Pumpkin Pie
THE FEAST FOR 8 ALSO INCLUDES:


ULTIMATE PACKAGES
Ideal for large groups—and adding a little extra luxe toyour celebration.
CAVIAR FOR FOUR | $150
White Sturgeon Caviar 50gr • Mini Blinis • Crème Fraîche
CAVIAR FOR EIGHT | $300
White Sturgeon Caviar 100gr • Mini Blinis • Crème Fraîche
APPETIZERS FOR FOUR | $90
Giuseppe’s Stuffed Mushrooms • Oven-Roasted Clams
The Entertainer Cheeseboard
APPETIZERS FOR EIGHT | $140
Giuseppe’s Stuffed Mushrooms • Oven-Roasted Clams
The Entertainer Cheeseboard
DESSERT FOR FOUR | $50
Seasonal Fruit Bowl • Artisanal Cookies
DESSERT FOR EIGHT | $90
Seasonal Fruit Bowl • Artisanal Cookie
GOURMET CATERING
International cheeses. Prime filet mignon. Chocolate
desserts. All our signature platters can all be found on this
menu—along with a new selection of half and whole trays
of Citarella favorites (like Lasagna Bolognese).
ORDERING FROM OUR MENU
There are four ways you can order for Thanksgiving:
ONLINE: Citarella.com/Holiday
IN-STORE: Citarella.com/Locations
EMAIL: [email protected]
CALL: 212-874-0383 (NYC)
631-283-6600 (HAMPTONS)
203-861-6900 (GREENWICH)


THANKSGIVING CUTOFF DATES
Friday, November 20th for Monday, November 23rd
Friday, November 20th for Tuesday, November 24th
Friday, November 20th for Wednesday, November 25th
Monday, November 23rd for Friday, November 27th
When placing your order, you have the option to select
either store pickup or local delivery (where available).
Please note: personal shopping, catering, or delivery fees
may apply.
ORDERING SEAFOOD
FOR THANKSGIVING
In addition to our menu, you can also order our fresh
seafood online for nationwide, overnight shipping, as well
as local delivery. Some of our favorite holiday items
include:
• Curated seafood kits—like our Raw Bar and fresh
Oyster Flight.
• Our sustainable caviar, from Osetra to our new Kaluga.
• Luxuriously silky smoked seafood.
• Pristine catches like Nova Scotia lobster,
Norwegian salmon, and more.
Explore our entire selection, and be sure to
place your order by 4 PM on the following dates:
Monday, November 23rd for Wednesday, November 25th


EXPERT COOKING RESOURCES


HOW TO CARVE
A TURKEY
Step-by-step instructions
from our Master Butcher &
Meat Specialist, Charlie.
VIEW NOW


CHEESE BOARD
Including suggested
quantities, pairings, and
optimal serving temperature.
VIEW NOW


HOLIDAY
TIPS
Your full-service road map for
holiday cooking, from warming
chef-prepared dishes to
recommended portion sizes.
VIEW NOW
FEATURED THANKSGIVING RECIPES
You've brought home premium ingredients. Now, turn them into something exceptional.
GOURMET GIFT INSPIRATION
Presents that leave a lasting (and delicious) impression.


Fresh, artfully designed bouquets
and arrangements from our local
vendor in the Hamptons.
FIND YOUR MARKET


BOMBS
Made from rich, decadent
chocolate; just add warm milk
and watch your drink bloom.
STORE LOCATOR


WHERE IS HOLIDAY CATERING AVAILABLE?
Our menu items are available for local pickup or delivery within the
New York City, Hamptons, and Greenwich, Connecticut area.
WHAT IF I MISS THE MENU CUTOFF DATES?
turkey at our Prepared Foods Counter. Savory stuffings, glazed sweet potatoes, and sautéed string beans
in our refrigerator case. And of course, golden-brown, freshly baked pies at our Pastry Counter.
Our dedicated team members will be ready to help you find whatever you need.
It’s always an honor to join your holiday table.



















