The store will not work correctly in the case when cookies are disabled.
We use cookies.These cookies enhance your experience and improve our website. Certain cookies are necessary and can't be turned off,
but we also allow others to place cookies to track the performance of our website and deliver personalized content and ads. You can select your preference using the buttons.
SPECIAL HOURS: Our Village market will close at 4 PM on Saturday, October 31st for the Halloween Parade.
Nor’easter Update. All stores are operating at normal hours. Stay safe out there!
Thanksgiving orders are open! Explore our Holiday Menu and make your selections today. VIEW MENU
This is a Fisherman’s Request item.*Peconic oysters boast a medium cup providing a liquor that's very briny, a little sweet, and present a flavor that’s unmistakably touched by the clean, mineral-rich water of Peconic Bay. We source these oysters from longtime oysterman, Howard Pickerell, owner of Peconic Pride in New York’s East End. These local oysters—with shells about three to five inches in length—are like wisps of silk. *This item is based on what’s in the catch of the day. If unavailable, we can help. Please see your options at checkout.
Savor this Peconic Oyster freshly shucked on the half shell.
Portion Size
When enjoying Peconic Oysters raw we recommend 6-12 pieces as an appetizer when serving raw oysters and clams. The size of this order is 1 dozen, which serves 1-2 people.
“Grilled, whole fish pairs well with a crisp sauvignon blanc or sparkling white.”
Wines & Spirits Director
Michael
A LIFETIME IN SEAFOOD.
COVER TO COVER.
With a passion for seafood more than 40 years in the making, no one is more qualified to teach you how to cook fish than Citarella’s Owner and Original Fishmonger, Joe Gurrera. Joe Knows Fish is collection of his very best, tried-and true recipes that focuses on simple preparations and the absolute freshest ingredients.
Did you know that Citarella owner, Joe Gurrera also owns Lockwood & Winant, a wholesale seafood company at the Fulton Fish Market? Joe has relationships with trusted fishermen worldwide, ensuring we offer the widest variety, highest quality, freshest seafood. Many of our fishmongers have worked with Joe for decades and have been trained to wield a knife like an artisan. They hand-cut, hand-shuck, and hand-prepare our seafood for your order.
*For our local customers, pre-order these Thanksgiving favorites for exclusive access to store pickup with our curbside concierge or local delivery (where available) the week of Thanksgiving, Monday, 11/23, Tuesday, 11/24 or Wednesday, 11/25.
INCLEMENT WEATHER NOTICE: Due to the expected snowstorm, our hours on Sunday, 1/25 and Monday, 1/26 will be adjusted. Please check our Store Locator page for more information.
THE SEAFOOD AUTHORITY
THE FRESHEST FISH DELIVERED TO YOUR DOOR
The finest & widest variety of fresh seafood from the most trusted sources
Aquaculture
