Share our passion for food by giving the Citarella
Gift Card. Good for
any occasion.
Need a housewarming gift, something to welcome a new mother home, or
some munchies for your teen away at school?
Having a business brunch, gallery opening, child’s birthday or
engagement party? Be sure to call us when you want them catered. Our
experienced staff can help you plan & provide simple to sumptuous
food for any festive occasion.
Happy Holiday
The holiday tradition starts with
Citarella
As a family run business, we know the importance that food can play in bringing the family together.
We are passionate about food and dedicated to bringing you the best selection of fresh foods and gourmet groceries.
Our expert team is ready to help with recipe ideas, serving suggestions, entertaining themes, and overall menu planning.
We have everything you need to make that memorable meal.
The following is a selection of Holiday Favorites from our
Holiday Menu.
Go to Page 01
Page 1 of 1
OSETRA CAVIAR 1.75 OZ
Slightly smaller than Beluga, Osetra has a somewhat nutty, pleasantly sweet flavor.
Price: $119.00 each
Total
AMERICAN CAVIAR 1.75 OZ
American Caviar is harvested in North American waters. Our American Caviar offers a very similar flavor as its cousins Sevruga & Beluga Caviars. These gray pearls have a delicate yet complex flavor that is rich with a creamy finish.
Price: $49.00 each
Total
WHITE STURGEON CAVIAR 1.75 OZ
Farm-raised white sturgeon, native to California, this elegant caviar that evokes the taste of the finest Osetra, with a nutty flavor thats at once smooth and robust.
Price: $99.00 each
Total
KUMAMOTO OYSTERS
From Washington State, this variety is delicately small & plump with a buttery texture & a mildly-briny-yet-creamy flavor.
Sold by the dozen. $22.99 per dozen.
Price: $22.99 each
Total
PRINCE EDWARD ISLAND OYSTERS
A welcoming bitter, lettuce-like flavor is the hallmark of this Canadian oyster whose flavor ends on a light, salty note.
Sold by the dozen. $18.99 per dozen.
Price: $18.99 each
Total
WELLFLEET OYSTERS
Similar to the capes but brinier, this Massachusetts variety is meaty & sweet.
Sold by the dozen. $18.99 per dozen.
Price: $18.99 each
Total
CAPE OYSTERS
Mildly sweet & as bracing as an Atlantic breeze, these meaty blue points come from Cape Cod.
Sold by the dozen. $14.99 per dozen.
Price: $14.99 each
Total
BLACK WINTER TRUFFLE
More emphatic than the summer variety, these black beauties are great sliced & tossed in an omelet or tucked under a soon-to-be-baked capons skin. Available January through May. About 2 ounces.
Price: $300.00 each
Total
WHITE TRUFFLE
Turn your next pasta, risotto or fondue into a splendid entrée by slicing this delicacy onto any of these. Available September through December. Since truffles vary in size we will make our best effort to send about 1 ounce.
Price: $350.00 each
Total
CITARELLA FREE RANGE TURKEY
Antibiotic free, our fresh Citarella Free Range Turkeys are exceptionally juicy and flavorful. For serving suggestions, we recommend 1 and ½ pounds (uncooked Turkey) per person. Cooking time is 13 minutes per pound for an unstuffed turkey.
Choose lbs.
Price: $2.99 per pound
Total
SMOKED HAM BONE-IN 14 to 16 LBS
Slowly cooked over hardwood, our Smoked Hams have the perfect balance of smoke and fresh pork flavor. Incredibly succulent and tender, our Smoked Hams are a festive way to celebrate the holidays.
Price: $111.84 each
Total
SMOKED HAM BONE-IN HALF 6 to 8 LBS
Slowly cooked over hardwood, our Smoked Hams have the perfect balance of smoke and fresh pork flavor. Incredibly succulent and tender, our Smoked Hams are a festive way to celebrate the holidays.
Price: $93.92 each
Total
SMOKED HAM BONE-IN SPIRAL CUT 14 to 16 LBS
Slowly cooked over hardwood, our Smoked Hams have the perfect balance of smoke and fresh pork flavor. Incredibly succulent and tender, our Smoked Hams are a festive way to celebrate the holidays.
Price: $95.84 each
Total
SMOKED HAM BONE-IN SPIRAL CUT HALF 6 to 8 LBS
Slowly cooked over hardwood, our Smoked Hams have the perfect balance of smoke and fresh pork flavor. Incredibly succulent and tender, our Smoked Hams are a festive way to celebrate the holidays.
Price: $55.92 each
Total
SMOKED HAM BONELESS 5 to 6 LBS
Slowly cooked over hardwood, our Smoked Hams have the perfect balance of smoke and fresh pork flavor. Incredibly succulent and tender, our Smoked Hams are a festive way to celebrate the holidays.
Price: $53.94 each
Total
SMOKED HAM BONELESS HALF 2 to 3 LBS
Slowly cooked over hardwood, our Smoked Hams have the perfect balance of smoke and fresh pork flavor. Incredibly succulent and tender, our Smoked Hams are a festive way to celebrate the holidays.
Price: $29.97 each
Total
SAUTEED STRING BEANS
We sautée fresh beans in EVOO to a perfectly crisp, yet tender consistency and lightly season to make a delicious addition to your meal.
Price: $7.99 per pound
Total
POACHED ASPARAGUS
Cooked until perfectly tender, drizzled with Citarella extra virgin olive and finished with colorful julienned peppers.
Price: $9.99 per pound
Total
SAUTEED BRUSSELS SPROUTS
Sauteed onions and extra virgin olive oil are tossed with whole tender Brussels sprouts.
Price: $7.99 per pound
Total
TURKEY GRAVY
Better than homemade and never any clumps, our Turkey Gravy starts with our own freshly-made turkey stock, turkey giblets, butter, flour, sherry, fresh sage, sea salt, and pepper.
Price: $4.99 pint
Total
SAUSAGE STUFFING
Savory and satisfying, our Sausage Stuffing is made with our fresh baked corn bread, house-made fresh sausage, fresh fennel and celery, extra virgin olive oil, spices, sea salt, and our own chicken stock. Serving Suggestions are 1/4 to 1/3 LB per person.
Price: $7.99 per pound
Total
CHESTNUT STUFFING
With a hint of sweetness from whole roasted chestnuts, our Chestnut Stuffing is made with our fresh baked corn bread, fresh celery, extra virgin olive oil, sea salt, pepper, and our own chicken stock. Serving Suggestions are 1/4 to 1/3 LB per person.
Price: $7.99 per pound
Total
WILD RICE STUFFING
With a delicious, roasted nutty flavor and pleasing texture from wild rice, our Wild Rice Stuffing is made with our fresh baked corn bread, fresh celery, extra virgin olive oil, sea salt, pepper, and our own chicken stock. Serving Suggestions are 1/4 to 1/3 LB per person.
Price: $7.99 per pound
Total
SWEET POTATO PRALINE
Reminiscent of a classic sweet potato pie, our Sweet Potato Praline is made with mashed pure sweet potatoes, brown sugar, butter, orange zest, and walnuts. Serving Suggestions are 1/4 to 1/3 LB per person.
Price: $7.99 per pound
Total
GLAZED SWEET POTATOES
Baked to tasty perfection, our Glazed Sweet Potatoes are made with sweet potatoes, brown sugar, butter, and orange rind. Serving Suggestions are 1/4 to 1/3 LB per person.
Price: $7.99 per pound
Total
CRANBERRY CONSERVE WITH PECANS
Not too tart or too sweet, our Cranberry Conserve is just perfect. We start with fresh whole cranberries bursting with flavor and then gently cook them with brandy, pecans, orange juice, and sugar.
Price: $6.99 pint
Total
TRADITIONAL GEFILTE FISH
New York’s Best Gefilte Fish - as good as your Grandmother’s. Fresh Whitefish and Pike are combined with onions and delicately poached with carrots in aspic for an unmatched taste.
Price: $7.99 per pound
Total
CHALLAH
Our Challah is hand rolled and freshly baked everyday by us.
Price: $5.99 each
Total
MATZOH BALL SOUP
Just like Grandma's, we start with our freshly made free range chicken stock. We then add fresh vegetables and light, fluffy Matzoh Balls.
Price: $4.99 each
Total
CHOPPED CHICKEN LIVER
We use only delicate liver morsels from all-natural free range chicken and sauté them with onions before chopping and seasoning for a classic taste.
Price: $3.99 each
Total
PICKLED HERRING - CREAM
Flavorful chunks of Herring Fillets in sour cream or vinegar with a touch of sugar.
Price: $4.99 each
Total
PICKLED HERRING - BRINE
Flavorful chunks of Herring Fillets in sour cream or vinegar with a touch of sugar.
Price: $4.99 each
Total
BRAISED PRIME BEEF BRISKET
Our expert Butchers carefully hand trim our Prime Beef to create our First-Cut Beef Brisket which our Executive Chef then slowly braises for a perfect flavor, juiciness, and tenderness. Be sure to order extra Brisket Gravy.
Price: $18.98 per pound
Total
FLOURESS CHOCOLATE CAKE
Luxuriously rich and creamy chocolate ganache-style cake finished with dark cocoa powder.
Price: $18.99 each
Total
VANILLA MERINGUE CAKE
4 layers of light and fluffy vanilla sponge cake with freshly made Chantilly cream. Topped with flambéed Italian meringue, our Vanilla Meringue Cake is a refreshing treat and not too sweet.
Price: $19.99 each
Total
CORN BREAD
Moist from using whole corn kernels, our Corn Bread starts with organic cornmeal for an unbelievably tasty corn taste.
Price: $4.99 each
Total
ARTISAN PUMPKIN PIES
Lovingly hand-crafted, our Pumpkin Pies start with fresh sugar pumpkins (no canned product for us) that are baked to heavenly perfection. Using our special spice mix of cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, cloves, black pepper, and sea salt, our Pumpkin Pies are a creamy delight with a flaky, comforting crust.
Price: $12.99 each
Total
ARTISAN APPLE PIES
Our tasty Apple Pies start with artfully hand peeled and cut apples that have been carefully selected. Each Apple Pie is brimming with a couple pounds of apples. With a hint of cinnamon and the flakiest crust around, our artisan Apple Pies set the new standard on what this old-fashioned classic is all about.
Price: $15.99 each
Total
ARTISAN PECAN PIES
In a flaky buttery crust, our freshly baked Pecan Pie is a delicious, sumptous nutty treat with whole pecans throughout - on top and in the filling.
Price: $17.99 each
Total
SOUR CREAM APPLE PIE
Starting with hand peeled and cored apples, our freshly baked Sour Cream Apple Pie uses real Sour Cream and Lemon Zest for a light tanginess complemented by a delicious cinnamon, walnut crumble topping.
